Vintage Bagley Fishing Lures
Shop here for old Bagley balsa wood lures with brass hangers, Bang-O-Lures, wedge cut lures and many more, with different rare Bagley lures on sale daily.1,517 items
BAGLEY SHALLOW DIVING SMALL FRY SHAD 5 FISHING LURE ( BIG FISH LURE )
- Details »
- Bid on This Item (0 bids) »
- Buy Now for $30.75 »
- Bid: $23.50
- Shipping: Based on Zip
- Time left: 10 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Mount Pleasant, TX, USA ZIP 754**
- Shipping Type: Calculated
- Handling Time: 3 business days
- Seller: ifishetex
Feedback: 179 / 100% Top-Rated Seller 
- See other items for sale from ifishetex
Bagley’s Dub’L 07 Secret Fish Agent 5” New 9C4 Tough Color! 007
- Details »
- Buy Now for $85.00 »
- Shipping: Free
- Time left: 15 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Huntsville, AL, USA ZIP 358**
- Shipping Type: Free
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: bourbonrose
Feedback: 1,491 / 100% Top-Rated Seller - See other items for sale from bourbonrose
Bagley’s Dub’L 07 Secret Fish Agent 3” New HT14 Copper Pea Tough Color! 007JR
- Details »
- Buy Now for $45.00 »
- Shipping: Free
- Time left: 19 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Huntsville, AL, USA ZIP 358**
- Shipping Type: Free
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: bourbonrose
Feedback: 1,491 / 100% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from bourbonrose
Bagley’s Lit’L John Rare Lure In HTF Color 6F Frog 🐸 New in Pkg
- Details »
- Buy Now for $35.00 »
- Shipping: Free
- Time left: 1 hr 19 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Huntsville, AL, USA ZIP 358**
- Shipping Type: Free
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: bourbonrose
Feedback: 1,491 / 100% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from bourbonrose
Bagley’s Lit’L John Rare Lure In Shad Color SH4 New in Pkg
- Details »
- Buy Now for $25.00 »
- Shipping: Free
- Time left: 1 hr 21 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Huntsville, AL, USA ZIP 358**
- Shipping Type: Free
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: bourbonrose
Feedback: 1,491 / 100% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from bourbonrose
Bagley’s RARE Weedless Spittin’ Twitcher Lure In HTF Color BYT New in Pkg
- Details »
- Buy Now for $85.00 »
- Shipping: Free
- Time left: 1 hr 26 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Huntsville, AL, USA ZIP 358**
- Shipping Type: Free
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: bourbonrose
Feedback: 1,491 / 100% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from bourbonrose
Bagley’s RARE Weedless Spittin’ Twitcher Lure In HTF Color GBT New in Pkg
- Details »
- Buy Now for $85.00 »
- Shipping: Free
- Time left: 1 hr 28 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Huntsville, AL, USA ZIP 358**
- Shipping Type: Free
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: bourbonrose
Feedback: 1,491 / 100% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from bourbonrose
Vintage Bagley’s Bang-O 5 Inch Blue, Chrome And Black
- Details »
- Buy Now for $11.99 »
- Shipping: Based on Zip
- Time left: 2 hrs 36 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Bentonville, AR, USA ZIP 727**
- Shipping Type: Calculated
- Expedited Shipping
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: rejunkulous2016
Feedback: 612 / 100% Top-Rated Seller - See other items for sale from rejunkulous2016
8-20 Early Vintage Bagley's Diving Bang O-B III 3 Brass Hardware Fishing Lure
- Details »
- Buy Now for $22.24 »
- Shipping: $2.69
- Time left: 4 hrs 6 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Hazleton, IA, USA ZIP 506**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: 78customs
Feedback: 2,962 / 99.7%
- See other items for sale from 78customs
Vintage Mini Bagley Bang O Lure
- Details »
- Bid on This Item (0 bids) »
- Buy Now for $10.00 »
- Bid: $5.00
- Shipping: Based on Zip
- Time left: 4 hrs 44 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Charlotte, NC, USA ZIP 282**
- Shipping Type: Calculated
- Handling Time: 2 business days
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: tidewill
Feedback: 526 / 100%
- See other items for sale from tidewill
Bagley Salty Dog Spoon 1oz 1DS-74 great color!
- Details »
- Buy Now for $29.99 »
- Shipping: $4.00
- Time left: 5 hrs 33 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Huntsville, AL, USA ZIP 358**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: bourbonrose
Feedback: 1,491 / 100% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from bourbonrose
Bagley Salty Dog Spoon 1oz 1DS-04 nice color!
- Details »
- Buy Now for $29.99 »
- Shipping: $4.00
- Time left: 5 hrs 44 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Huntsville, AL, USA ZIP 358**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: bourbonrose
Feedback: 1,491 / 100% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from bourbonrose
Vintage Fishing Lures Lot 3 Bagleys Jitterbug Tackle Outdoors Sportsman Mancave
- Details »
- Buy Now for $59.97 »
- Shipping: Based on Zip
- Time left: 5 hrs 52 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Forest Park, GA, USA ZIP 302**
- Shipping Type: Calculated
- Handling Time: 2 business days
- Seller: redheadchickboutique1
Feedback: 918 / 100%
- See other items for sale from redheadchickboutique1
Bagley tough Diving Kill'rB2 Dredge new in pkg Tennessee Shad color
- Details »
- Buy Now for $19.99 »
- Shipping: $4.00
- Time left: 6 hrs 24 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Huntsville, AL, USA ZIP 358**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: bourbonrose
Feedback: 1,491 / 100% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from bourbonrose
Bagleys fishing lure & other swivels & hooks (Lot#14890)
- Details »
- Buy Now for $8.95 »
- Shipping: $4.50
- Time left: 7 hrs
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Wernersville, PA, USA ZIP 195**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 3 business days
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: zippythings39
Feedback: 4,978 / 99.9% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from zippythings39
Bagley’s Bang - O - Lure #SPS4-BS Balsa Rare Find New USA Look@My Lure Lots
- Details »
- Bid on This Item (0 bids) »
- Buy Now for $19.99 »
- Bid: $14.99
- Shipping: $7.99
- Time left: 7 hrs 50 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Cookeville, TN, USA ZIP 385**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Expedited Shipping
- Handling Time: 2 business days
- Seller: dale_hollow_custom_topwater_lures
Feedback: 2,261 / 100%
- See other items for sale from dale_hollow_custom_topwater_lures
BAGLEY'S BAIT CO, SQUARE LIP, BB3, FOIL/BLACK BACK, EXC. COND., MARKED, USED
- Details »
- Buy Now for $9.50 »
- Shipping: $4.00
- Time left: 8 hrs 5 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Knoxville, TN, USA ZIP 379**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 3 business days
- Seller: williamedwards88506
Feedback: 1,521 / 100% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from williamedwards88506
"Vintage" bagley's "Small Fry Shad (Tiger Stripe ) 2 3/8 " Body 3 3/8 inc. Bill
- Details »
- Bid on This Item (0 bids) »
- Buy Now for $23.75 »
- Bid: $17.95
- Shipping: Based on Zip
- Time left: 16 hrs 12 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Mount Pleasant, TX, USA ZIP 754**
- Shipping Type: Calculated
- Handling Time: 3 business days
- Seller: ifishetex
Feedback: 180 / 100% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from ifishetex
Vintage Bagley's Kill'r B1 Fishing Lure DARK CRAYFISH CRANKBAIT NEW IN PACKAGE
- Details »
- Buy Now for $34.00 »
- Shipping: Free
- Time left: 17 hrs 18 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Rutherfordton, NC, USA ZIP 281**
- Shipping Type: Free
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: parker3fishing
Feedback: 11,416 / 100% Top-Rated Seller - See other items for sale from parker3fishing
Bagley ET 3 Fishing Lure In Great Shape
- Details »
- Buy Now for $12.00 »
- Shipping: $5.00
- Time left: 17 hrs 19 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Poplar Grove, IL, USA ZIP 610**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 5 business days
- Seller: petros513
Feedback: 1,306 / 100% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from petros513
Vintage Bagley's Kill'r B1 Fishing Lure H69T COLOR CRANKBAIT NEW IN PACKAGE
- Details »
- Buy Now for $40.00 »
- Shipping: Free
- Time left: 17 hrs 21 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Rutherfordton, NC, USA ZIP 281**
- Shipping Type: Free
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: parker3fishing
Feedback: 11,414 / 100% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from parker3fishing
Vintage Bagley's Kill'r B1 Fishing Lure TENNESSEE SHAD COLOR CRANKBAIT NOS NIP
- Details »
- Buy Now for $40.00 »
- Shipping: Free
- Time left: 17 hrs 24 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Rutherfordton, NC, USA ZIP 281**
- Shipping Type: Free
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: parker3fishing
Feedback: 11,414 / 100% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from parker3fishing
Bagley’s DB3 TS Ten Shad Dredge
- Details »
- Buy Now for $12.99 »
- Shipping: $3.75
- Time left: 17 hrs 39 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Louisville, KY, USA ZIP 402**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: thetacklecloset
Feedback: 17,444 / 100%
- See other items for sale from thetacklecloset
Bagley’s DKB2 TS Ten Shad
- Details »
- Buy Now for $12.99 »
- Shipping: $3.75
- Time left: 17 hrs 39 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Louisville, KY, USA ZIP 402**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: thetacklecloset
Feedback: 17,444 / 100%
- See other items for sale from thetacklecloset
Bagley’s KB1 DC9 Dark Crayfish On Chart
- Details »
- Buy Now for $12.99 »
- Shipping: $3.75
- Time left: 17 hrs 39 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Louisville, KY, USA ZIP 402**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: thetacklecloset
Feedback: 17,444 / 100%
- See other items for sale from thetacklecloset
Bagley’s DDKB2 Double Deep H69T Fire Tiger
- Details »
- Buy Now for $12.99 »
- Shipping: $3.75
- Time left: 17 hrs 39 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Louisville, KY, USA ZIP 402**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: thetacklecloset
Feedback: 17,444 / 100%
- See other items for sale from thetacklecloset
Bagley’s DB2 DC9 Dark Crayfish On Chart
- Details »
- Buy Now for $12.99 »
- Shipping: $3.75
- Time left: 17 hrs 39 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Louisville, KY, USA ZIP 402**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: thetacklecloset
Feedback: 17,444 / 100%
- See other items for sale from thetacklecloset
Bagley’s DB2 TS Ten Shad
- Details »
- Buy Now for $12.99 »
- Shipping: $3.75
- Time left: 17 hrs 39 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Louisville, KY, USA ZIP 402**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: thetacklecloset
Feedback: 17,444 / 100%
- See other items for sale from thetacklecloset
Bagley’s KB2 Super Shallow H69T Fire Tiger Chip In Bait
- Details »
- Buy Now for $12.99 »
- Shipping: $3.75
- Time left: 17 hrs 39 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Louisville, KY, USA ZIP 402**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: thetacklecloset
Feedback: 17,444 / 100%
- See other items for sale from thetacklecloset
Bagley’s DB3 TS Ten Shad
- Details »
- Buy Now for $12.99 »
- Shipping: $3.75
- Time left: 17 hrs 39 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Louisville, KY, USA ZIP 402**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: thetacklecloset
Feedback: 17,444 / 100%
- See other items for sale from thetacklecloset
Bagley’s DB2 BS Black On Silver Foil
- Details »
- Buy Now for $12.99 »
- Shipping: $3.75
- Time left: 17 hrs 39 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Louisville, KY, USA ZIP 402**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: thetacklecloset
Feedback: 17,444 / 100%
- See other items for sale from thetacklecloset
Bagley’s DB3 GSH Gray Shad
- Details »
- Buy Now for $12.99 »
- Shipping: $3.75
- Time left: 17 hrs 39 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Louisville, KY, USA ZIP 402**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: thetacklecloset
Feedback: 17,444 / 100%
- See other items for sale from thetacklecloset
VINTAGE BAGLEY UNMARKED MODEL FISHING LURE 2" firtgr
- Details »
- Buy Now for $10.00 »
- Shipping: $3.90
- Time left: 20 hrs 36 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Sartell, MN, USA ZIP 563**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: csam921
Feedback: 6,534 / 100% Top-Rated Seller - See other items for sale from csam921
BAGLEY'S BAIT CO,"DIVING B II", 2 1/2" BODY, GOLD SCALES, IVORY SIDES&BELLY,USED
- Details »
- Buy Now for $12.00 »
- Shipping: $4.00
- Time left: 20 hrs 57 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Knoxville, TN, USA ZIP 379**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 5 business days
- Seller: williamedwards88506
Feedback: 1,521 / 100% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from williamedwards88506
Vintage 2 Bagley DB3 new in pack, DB3 CSY, & DB3 Parrot fishing lures
- Details »
- Buy Now for $60.00 »
- Shipping: $8.00
- Time left: 20 hrs 59 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Punta Gorda, FL, USA ZIP 339**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 3 business days
- Seller: tylesout-0
Feedback: 323 / 100%
- See other items for sale from tylesout-0
Bagley’s Diving Bang-O B Large Musky Lure New in Package DB M9
- Details »
- Buy Now for $25.00 »
- Shipping: $6.95
- Time left: 21 hrs 40 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Hayward, WI, USA ZIP 548**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 3 business days
- Seller: flagisld
Feedback: 5,628 / 100% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from flagisld
Bagley Musky Old Fishing Lure 4
- Details »
- Buy Now for $13.00 »
- Shipping: $4.00
- Time left: 21 hrs 44 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Midlothian, TX, USA ZIP 760**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 3 business days
- Seller: lurejunky
Feedback: 2,712 / 99.4%
- See other items for sale from lurejunky
BEAUTIFUL VINTAGE BAGLEY LURE 7/27/20P 2-7/8"
- Details »
- Buy Now for $8.95 »
- Shipping: $4.95
- Time left: 21 hrs 57 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Saint Cloud, MN, USA ZIP 563**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: dano1155
Feedback: 19,678 / 99.9% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from dano1155
Rare Bagley Bang o lure you orange gold tiger colored. Size #4 floating Rare !
- Details »
- Buy Now for $25.00 »
- Shipping: Free
- Time left: 22 hrs 15 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Gillett, WI, USA ZIP 541**
- Shipping Type: Free
- Handling Time: 3 business days
- Seller: fishntreasures
Feedback: 5,120 / 98.1%
- See other items for sale from fishntreasures
BEAUTIFUL VINTAGE BAGLEY MINNOW LURE 7/27/20 4"
- Details »
- Buy Now for $8.95 »
- Shipping: $4.95
- Time left: 23 hrs 49 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Saint Cloud, MN, USA ZIP 563**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: dano1155
Feedback: 19,678 / 99.9% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from dano1155
Vintage Bagley Diving B's Fishing Lure DB3 - DC9 11/16 - unopened
- Details »
- Buy Now for $24.00 »
- Shipping: Based on Zip
- Time left: 1 day 32 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Hopkinsville, KY, USA ZIP 422**
- Shipping Type: Calculated
- Handling Time: 3 business days
- Seller: 270davidk
Feedback: 78 / 100% Top-Rated Seller - See other items for sale from 270davidk
VINTAGE BAGLEY BANG O LURE #5 SPINNER FISHING LURE SILVER/STRIPES
- Details »
- Buy Now for $75.00 »
- Shipping: Based on Zip
- Time left: 1 day 2 hrs 21 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Houston, TX, USA ZIP 770**
- Shipping Type: Calculated
- Handling Time: 3 business days
- Seller: eldompero
Feedback: 101 / 100%
- See other items for sale from eldompero
BAGLEY 2 1/4” Square Lip V Wood Lure With All BRASS WIRE Hardware-GREAT COLOR #1
- Details »
- Buy Now for $35.00 »
- Shipping: $5.95
- Time left: 1 day 2 hrs 26 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Santa Clarita, CA, USA ZIP 913**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: steinman1999
Feedback: 17,925 / 99.7% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from steinman1999
BAGLEY 1 3/4” Wood Lure With All BRASS WIRE Hardware-PARROT COLOR??
- Details »
- Buy Now for $35.00 »
- Shipping: $5.95
- Time left: 1 day 2 hrs 37 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Santa Clarita, CA, USA ZIP 913**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: steinman1999
Feedback: 17,925 / 99.7% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from steinman1999
BAGLEY 2 3/8” Wood Lure With All BRASS WIRE Hardware-GREAT COLOR #A
- Details »
- Buy Now for $50.00 »
- Shipping: $5.95
- Time left: 1 day 2 hrs 44 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Santa Clarita, CA, USA ZIP 913**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: steinman1999
Feedback: 17,925 / 99.7% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from steinman1999
BAGLEY 2 3/8” Wood Lure With All BRASS WIRE Hardware-GREAT COLOR #A1
- Details »
- Buy Now for $35.00 »
- Shipping: $5.95
- Time left: 1 day 3 hrs 5 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Santa Clarita, CA, USA ZIP 913**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: steinman1999
Feedback: 17,925 / 99.7% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from steinman1999
Rare Vintage Bagley Balsa Small Fry Shad Super Diver 4DDSF5-GFS Gold Foil Shad
- Details »
- Buy Now for $49.95 »
- Shipping: Based on Zip
- Time left: 1 day 3 hrs 9 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Beaufort, NC, USA ZIP 285**
- Shipping Type: Calculated
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: cullycreek
Feedback: 248 / 100% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from cullycreek
Rare Vintage Bagley Balsa Small Fry Shad 4DSF5-CSH Crippled Shad
- Details »
- Buy Now for $39.95 »
- Shipping: Based on Zip
- Time left: 1 day 3 hrs 10 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Beaufort, NC, USA ZIP 285**
- Shipping Type: Calculated
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: cullycreek
Feedback: 248 / 100% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from cullycreek
Rare Vintage Bagley Balsa Small Fry Shad 4DSF5-SH4 Shad on White
- Details »
- Buy Now for $39.95 »
- Shipping: Based on Zip
- Time left: 1 day 3 hrs 10 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Beaufort, NC, USA ZIP 285**
- Shipping Type: Calculated
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: cullycreek
Feedback: 248 / 100% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from cullycreek
BAGLEY 2 1/2” Balsa Wood Lure In AWESOME HARD TO FIND COLOR!!
- Details »
- Buy Now for $95.00 »
- Shipping: $5.95
- Time left: 1 day 3 hrs 18 mins
- Item Condition:
- Item Location: Santa Clarita, CA, USA ZIP 913**
- Shipping Type: Flat Rate
- Handling Time: 1 business day
- Returns Accepted
- Seller: steinman1999
Feedback: 17,925 / 99.7% Top-Rated Seller
- See other items for sale from steinman1999